Failure to Deliver Wedding Jewellery After Taking Advance Payment Is Deficiency in Service: Consumer Commission Orders Rs 7.1 Lakh Relief

The Kangra District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Himachal Pradesh has directed a jeweller to refund Rs 6 lakh to a customer who did not receive gold ornaments ordered for family weddings despite making advance payments. The commission also awarded Rs 1 lakh in compensation and punitive damages, along with Rs 10,000 in litigation expenses.

In its November 12 order, the commission held that the jeweller’s repeated failure to honour the order, followed by a refusal to deliver the ornaments or return the outstanding amount shortly before the customer’s sister’s wedding, constituted deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.

The commission, comprising President Hemanshu Mishra and members Arti Sood and Narayan Thakur, directed the jeweller and its proprietors and partners to comply with the order within 45 days. Their liability was made joint and several.

Commission Finds Deliberate Breach of Consumer Trust

The consumer forum found that the jeweller’s conduct was not merely a case of commercial negligence. It described the prolonged retention of advance payments, repeated assurances of delivery and last-minute refusal as exploitative conduct warranting punitive damages.

READ ALSO  Consumer Commission Orders Society to Refund ₹3 Lakh FD With Interest, Pay Compensation for Delayed Repayment

According to the commission, the customer had been kept waiting for more than three and a half years after paying substantial advances for customised bridal jewellery. The situation became particularly serious when the jeweller allegedly stopped communicating and refused to fulfil the order just 48 hours before the wedding.

The commission observed that this conduct placed the complainant in an avoidable financial crisis, forcing him to arrange replacement ornaments at higher prevailing market prices.

It held that punitive damages were justified both to address the jeweller’s conduct and to discourage similar practices by businesses dealing with consumers.

Jewellery Ordered in 2022 for Family Weddings

The dispute arose from an order placed on September 28, 2022, for gold ornaments intended for the complainant’s sister’s marriage and his own wedding.

The items included a mangalsutra, a bridal jewellery set with tika, bangles, chains and five customised rings.

READ ALSO  Consumer Commission Orders Replacement Of Rs 25 Lakh Bottling Machine, Awards Rs 75,000 Compensation For Deficient Service

The complainant paid Rs 8 lakh towards the order. Although the jeweller subsequently returned Rs 2 lakh, the remaining Rs 6 lakh was neither refunded nor adjusted through delivery of the ornaments.

The customer alleged that the shop repeatedly postponed delivery despite assurances that the jewellery would be ready.

When he approached the jeweller in 2025 ahead of his sister’s wedding, he was asked to return first in July, then in September and subsequently around Diwali.

The complainant’s sister was scheduled to marry on April 24, 2026. However, when he visited the shop two days before the ceremony, the jeweller allegedly refused both to supply the ornaments and to return the outstanding payment.

The complainant told the commission that the refusal compelled him to purchase alternative jewellery at increased market rates, resulting in financial hardship and mental distress.

Jeweller Failed to Contest Complaint

READ ALSO  Rajasthan Consumer Commission Fines Honda Dealer For Selling Old Car As New Model

Despite receiving notice, the jeweller did not participate in the proceedings. The commission consequently proceeded ex parte and considered the evidence submitted by the complainant.

It noted that the jeweller’s decision not to contest the proceedings meant that the complainant’s evidence remained unrebutted and unchallenged.

After examining the material, the commission concluded that the customer’s allegations established deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.

Refund, Compensation and Punitive Damages Awarded

The commission ordered the jeweller, along with its proprietors and partners, to pay the following amounts:

  • Rs 6,00,000 as refund of the outstanding advance payment.
  • Rs 50,000 as compensation.
  • Rs 50,000 as punitive damages.
  • Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.

The total amount payable is Rs 7.1 lakh, with the commission directing compliance within 45 days.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles