Emphasizing the need for humility and a respectful demeanor in the judiciary, the Supreme Court on Monday ordered the provisional reinstatement of Nazmeen Singh, a Punjab Judicial Services officer, whose conduct had previously led to her dismissal. The decision was delivered by Justices Surya Kant and N Kotiswar Singh, who highlighted the importance of judicial officers being humane, polite, and empathetic in their interactions.
Nazmeen Singh’s reinstatement by the Punjab and Haryana High Court is contingent upon her commitment to maintaining proper conduct with bar members, litigants, and colleagues. This condition reflects the court’s proactive stance on ensuring that judicial officers uphold the dignity and decorum of their positions.
The case dates back to incidents involving Singh’s alleged misbehavior with doctors at PGIMER Hospital in Chandigarh, which initially led to her termination on April 9, 2021. The Supreme Court, however, criticized the lack of adherence to the principles of natural justice in the handling of her dismissal.
Justice Surya Kant expressed concern over the broader issue of misconduct among judicial officers: “They do not behave properly with bar members, seniors, or the litigants. There is a need to sensitise our officers about their conduct.” He shared anecdotes from his experiences, underscoring the necessity for professional training and sensitization for judicial officers.
The bench praised the medical staff at PGIMER, acknowledging the challenging and relentless nature of their work, and emphasized that such professionals deserve utmost respect. Justice Kant remarked on the essential role of respect and understanding within all professional interactions, particularly highlighting the demanding environment at medical facilities like PGIMER.
As part of her reinstatement, Singh may be posted in Patiala, Punjab, where a senior woman judicial officer could provide mentorship and oversight. This arrangement aims to support her reintegration into the judicial system while ensuring she adheres to the required standards of conduct.
The matter has been adjourned for two weeks, during which Singh is expected to file an undertaking before the registrar general of the high court, affirming her commitment to uphold the judiciary’s standards and to submit a copy to the Supreme Court.
