Can First and Second Appeal Arising Out of Two Proceedings Between Same Parties and For Same Property be Combined? SC Answers

The Supreme Court has ruled that a first appeal and a second appeal arising out of two proceedings cannot be combined and disposed of by a single judgment, even if the parties are essentially the same and the property in dispute is common. 

The court noted that considerations made in cases of first and second appeals under Section 96 and Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 respectively are entirely different, particularly when it comes to the re-appreciation of evidence.

READ ALSO  Central Government has Approved the Appointment of Two Retired HC judges and One Sitting Judge to the NCLAT as Judicial Members

 As such, the court remanded the two appeals arising from two suits back to the Madras High Court, which had previously disposed of both by a common judgment. 

The High Court is required to consider the cases independently, with the matters to be de-linked and assessed separately for an independent decision.

READ ALSO  Threatening a person to withdraw complaint or FIR or settle the dispute would not attract Section 195A of the Indian Penal Code: SC