The Calcutta High Court on Friday extended the interim protection granted to Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee from coercive police action until January 29, 2027, in a case concerning alleged intimidatory remarks made during the West Bengal Assembly election campaign in April.
Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya, while allowing the extension, expressed concern over allegations that Banerjee had made statements criticising orders passed by the High Court. The judge observed that such conduct, if established, would be painful even if it did not amount to a wilful violation of judicial orders.
The observations came after lawyers representing the West Bengal government raised objections to Banerjee’s request for continued interim protection, alleging that the TMC leader had repeatedly targeted the High Court and the judiciary.
State Opposes Extension of Interim Protection
Additional Advocate General Rajdeep Majumdar, appearing for the West Bengal government, opposed the extension and submitted that Banerjee had continued making statements against the judiciary.
Majumdar also referred to a social media post allegedly made by Banerjee on Thursday, shortly after Justice Bhattacharyya declined to grant interim protection to his aide, Sumit Roy, in connection with criminal cases registered against him.
The state further drew the court’s attention to alleged comparisons made by Banerjee between judicial orders passed during different political periods.
Court Questions Public Criticism of Judicial Orders
Taking note of these submissions, Justice Bhattacharyya orally observed that Banerjee appeared to be inviting unnecessary trouble through his alleged statements.
The court expressed concern about the message such remarks could send to the public, particularly the political leader’s followers.
Justice Bhattacharyya observed that a litigant dissatisfied with a judicial order could challenge it before a higher court rather than publicly criticising the decision.
The judge also referred to comparisons allegedly being drawn between court orders passed during the current and previous political periods, observing that such statements were widely known through newspaper reports.
Separate Contempt Proceedings Against Banerjee
The observations come days after another bench of the Calcutta High Court initiated contempt proceedings against Banerjee.
On November 17, Justice Krishna Rao directed the issuance of a show-cause notice to the TMC MP after holding that his statements and social media posts against the court constituted ex facie criminal contempt.
Meanwhile, the criminal case in which Banerjee sought continued protection relates to an FIR registered over allegedly intimidatory statements made at a public meeting during the April Assembly election campaign.
The High Court had initially granted him interim protection in May. Despite the state’s opposition and the concerns raised during Friday’s hearing, Justice Bhattacharyya extended that protection until January 29, 2027.
