Kerala High Court Quashes Corruption FIR Against Minister K M Shaji Over Lack of Prior Sanction, Allows Preliminary Enquiry to Continue

The Kerala High Court on Thursday quashed a corruption FIR registered against state Local Self Government Minister K M Shaji in a disproportionate assets case, holding that the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) had proceeded without obtaining the mandatory prior sanction. However, the Court permitted the preliminary enquiry ordered by the special court to continue.

Justice C Jayachandran held that the investigating agency should have submitted its preliminary enquiry report to the special court instead of directly registering an FIR under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

The case arose from allegations that Shaji had accumulated assets disproportionate to his known sources of income while serving as an MLA between 2011 and 2020.

In 2020, Kozhikode-based lawyer M R Harish filed a complaint before the special court, which directed the vigilance authorities to conduct a preliminary enquiry into the allegations. The VACB subsequently registered an FIR against Shaji in 2021.

High Court Explains Procedure for Registering FIR

READ ALSO  Coal scam: HC suspends 4-yr sentence of ex-MP Darda and his son pending appeals

While examining Shaji’s petition, the High Court distinguished between conducting a preliminary enquiry and registering a criminal case based on its findings.

The Court found that the investigating officer had failed to follow the procedure contemplated in the special court’s order. Instead of registering the FIR independently, the officer should have placed the preliminary enquiry report before the special court.

According to the High Court, the report would have enabled the special court to determine whether an investigation should be ordered under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Since the FIR had been registered without the required sanction, the Court held that it could not be legally sustained.

READ ALSO  Normal Physical Hearing in Subordinate Courts of Uttarakhand From 02 January

Shaji Challenged Both FIR and Preliminary Enquiry

In his petition, Shaji questioned the legality of the FIR as well as the preliminary enquiry ordered by the special court.

He argued that a preliminary enquiry could not be used to determine whether allegations made in a complaint were genuine. Its limited purpose, according to his submissions, was to ascertain whether the information disclosed a cognisable offence.

Shaji further contended that once such an offence was disclosed, the appropriate legal course would be to register an FIR.

The state government defended the proceedings, submitting that the special court had merely directed the investigating officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry and submit a report.

The government also maintained that there was no legal prohibition against registering an FIR if a cognisable offence emerged during the enquiry.

READ ALSO  पाकिस्तान में काम करना किसी को भारत रक्षा नियम के नियम 130 के तहत 'शत्रु' नहीं बनाता: केरल हाईकोर्ट

Preliminary Enquiry Can Continue

The High Court declined to accept Shaji’s challenge to the preliminary enquiry itself, finding no ground to interfere with the special court’s direction.

Consequently, while setting aside the FIR registered in 2021, the Court allowed the preliminary enquiry to proceed in accordance with law.

The ruling leaves the investigating agency free to complete the court-directed preliminary enquiry, but requires it to follow the prescribed legal procedure before pursuing a criminal investigation against the minister.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles