Third-Party Purchaser Cannot Be Asked to Prove Company’s Board Meeting, Doctrine of Indoor Management Applies: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has held that an unrelated third-party buyer cannot be made to prove that a company’s Board meeting was held or that a resolution was passed at it, because those matters are within the personal knowledge of the company’s directors and shareholders. Applying the Doctrine of Indoor Management, the Court set aside NCLT and NCLAT orders that had cancelled a registered sale of 9 Acres 28 Guntas of company land.

A Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva allowed the appeal filed by Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. It also dismissed the petition that a director-shareholder had filed under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013.

Background of the Dispute

M/s J & A Avenues India Private Limited had only two shareholders and directors, a mother and her son, each holding 50% of the shares. In 2015, the son executed a sale deed transferring 9 Acres 28 Guntas of the Company’s land to Elaine Info Solutions. The deed referred to a Board Resolution dated 01.08.2015 that authorised him to sign it.

In 2018, the mother filed a petition before the NCLT. She said she had never been told about any Board meeting on 01.08.2015 and had not received a notice for one. She alleged that her son had transferred the land in collusion with the buyer.

The son told the NCLT that the total sale consideration was ₹12.275 crore, of which ₹7.91 crore was paid to him and ₹4.365 crore to the Company. The buyer said the consideration was only ₹4.365 crore. It said the ₹7.91 crore related to a separate agreement for the sale of the son’s own land, and that Mr. Naga Satish, its Director, had filed a suit for specific performance over that agreement.

READ ALSO  Rajasthan High Court Says: Consensual Physical Relations Between Adults Outside Marriage Not Offense

Tribunals Declared the Sale Void

In its order dated 02.08.2019, the NCLT held that no valid Board meeting could have been held without both directors taking part. It declared the resolution and the sale deed void, directed the Sub-Registrar to cancel the deed, and ordered the Company to return ₹4.365 crore with 8% interest. It also barred the son from the directorship for five years. The tribunal rejected the buyer’s plea of being a bona fide purchaser protected by the Doctrine of Indoor Management, and the NCLAT upheld the order on 18.03.2020.

Burden Lies on the Company, Not the Buyer

The Supreme Court held that the NCLT erred in requiring the buyer to prove that the mother had notice of the meeting or attended it. It said it was for the Company’s shareholders and directors to prove the meeting.

The Court observed, “Appellant being an unrelated third-party, cannot be made liable for proving the holding of the meeting and passing of a resolution in the said meeting.”

It added, “A third-party purchaser can only act bona fidely when one of the two directors, being a 50% shareholder produces a resolution of the Board of Directors.” The Bench held that “The Doctrine of Indoor Management would clearly come to apply in the present case.”

Mother Signed Accounts Disclosing the Sale

The Court noted that the Company received the sale consideration of ₹4.365 crore, recorded it in its audited books of accounts and used it. Both the mother and the son signed those accounts. Note 14 of the Notes to the Financial Statements stated that the Company “had executed a Sale Deed for sale of Ac. 9-28 Gts Agricultural Land” and mentioned the pending suit.

The Court also noted that the copy of the resolution referred to in the sale deed carried the mother’s signature attesting it as a true copy. She denied the signature, but she did not file any complaint or start criminal proceedings against her son for forgery.

READ ALSO  Sec 17 SARFAESI Act | Limitation of 45 Days Meant For Quick Enforcement of Security, Rules Supreme Court

Since the mother had signed the books, the Court held, “She cannot, therefore, be permitted to deny the said transaction or claim the ignorance to such a transaction.”

Petition Time-Barred, Adverse Inference Drawn

The Bench rejected the mother’s claim that her petition was within limitation. She had signed the balance sheet disclosing the sale on 02.09.2016, and her petition of 08.10.2018 challenged a registered sale deed after more than three years.

The Court found, “It is thus evident that a challenge to the Board Resolution dated 01.08.2015 and the sale deed dated 04.09.2015 has been made to counter the claim of Mr. Naga Satish in the suit for specific performance filed by him.”

The Company’s Income Tax Returns, which would have shown how capital gains on the sale were treated, were not placed before any forum. The Court said, “Since the Income Tax Returns have not been placed before this Court, an adverse inference needs to be drawn against the Company.”

Outcome

The Court held that the NCLT erred in declaring the resolution and sale deed void, in ordering cancellation and restoration of title, and in directing the refund with interest. It said the NCLAT “has erred in compounding the error by confirming the order of the NCLT.”

The Supreme Court set aside both orders and dismissed the mother’s Section 241 petition. It dismissed the son’s appeal as infructuous because his five-year debarment from the directorship had already ended. The Court clarified that it had not commented on the merits of the specific performance suit (O.S. No. 15/2016) pending before the First Additional District Judge, Sangareddy, and that the suit will be decided on its own merits.

READ ALSO  Supreme Court Announces Recruitment for Law Clerks in 2025, ₹80,000 Monthly Salary

Case Title: Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Ors.

Case No.: Civil Appeal No. 2821 of 2020 with Civil Appeal No. 6250 of 2021

Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva

Date: November 16, 2026

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles