CCPA Imposes Rs 1 Lakh Penalty on Bread Company for Misleading ‘100% Whole Wheat’ Claim

The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has imposed a penalty of Rs 1 lakh on a bread manufacturer for marketing a product as “100% Whole Wheat Bread” despite containing only 64 per cent whole wheat, below the prescribed minimum of 75 per cent required to use the description “Whole Wheat”.

In its October 28 order, the authority also directed the company to immediately discontinue the misleading advertisement, holding that the packaging misrepresented the product’s composition and constituted an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Chief Commissioner Nidhi Khare and Commissioner Anupuram Mishra found that the claim gave consumers the impression that the bread consisted entirely of whole wheat flour, although 36 per cent of its composition included other grains and ingredients.

The authority further noted that the disputed packaging continued to appear on quick-commerce platforms despite the company’s assurance that it had been replaced.

Company’s Explanation Rejected

During the proceedings, the manufacturer maintained that its bread complied with the approved formulation and applicable food safety requirements.

It argued that the description “100% Whole Wheat Bread” referred specifically to the flour used in the product, indicating that the wheat flour component consisted entirely of atta rather than refined flour or maida.

READ ALSO  Consumer Protection Act is prospective, meaning pending cases and rights/obligations created before its enactment will be adjudicated under Old Act: SCDRC

According to the company, the wording was intended to distinguish the bread from products containing refined wheat flour, not to suggest that every ingredient was whole wheat.

The CCPA rejected this explanation, finding that a claim concerning only one component could not be presented as a description of the entire product without adequately explaining its basis.

The authority observed that consumers would ordinarily understand the prominent “100%” declaration as referring to the bread’s overall composition rather than only its wheat flour component.

Complaint Raised Concerns Over Missing Disclosures

The proceedings originated from a complaint filed by advocates Gurmukh Singh Arora and Rahul Matharu, who questioned the marketing of the bread without disclosure of the proportion of whole wheat used.

They alleged that the packaging withheld essential information about the grain composition, preventing buyers from accurately assessing the product before purchasing it.

READ ALSO  Court Registry Not a ‘Service Provider’; Consumer Forum Can’t Examine Judicial Administration: Consumer Commission

Following the complaint, the CCPA initiated a preliminary inquiry under its statutory powers.

The inquiry examined whether the product’s labelling complied with the regulatory requirement that bread described as “Whole Wheat” must contain at least 75 per cent wheat content.

The authority concluded that the manufacturer’s representations could influence purchasing decisions by conveying an inaccurate impression of the bread’s ingredients and nutritional characteristics.

Revised Packaging Claim Questioned

The CCPA also examined the company’s assertion that it had modified the product packaging.

The manufacturer stated that older product images remained visible on some e-commerce platforms because those platforms retained artwork uploaded when the listings were first created. It claimed to have asked its e-commerce partners to replace those images with the updated packaging.

During the hearing, the authority sought documentary evidence through screen sharing to verify the claimed revision of the artwork from April 13, 2026.

However, the company’s counsel acknowledged that the revised packaging had actually been implemented only on August 3, 2026.

READ ALSO  Tanishq, Authorised Dealer Ordered To Pay Rs 47,500 After Consumer Forum Finds Defective Earring Lock Caused Loss

The CCPA found that this explanation did not satisfactorily account for the continued availability of the disputed packaging after the stated implementation date.

Consumer Reach Considered in Assessing Misleading Claims

The authority also considered the potential impact of the advertisement on consumers, observing that the number of people exposed to misleading packaging was relevant when assessing its consequences.

It noted that products reaching larger markets could expose more consumers to inaccurate descriptions or inadequate disclosures, increasing the potential impact of such representations.

The CCPA ultimately held that the “100% Whole Wheat” claim was misleading and capable of creating confusion about the bread’s actual composition.

Finding the advertisement and associated marketing practice in violation of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the authority ordered its immediate discontinuation and imposed a monetary penalty of Rs 1 lakh on the company.

Law Trend
Law Trendhttps://lawtrend.in/
Legal News Website Providing Latest Judgments of Supreme Court and High Court

Related Articles

Latest Articles