The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday delivered a scathing critique of the West Bengal health department’s lack of concern for citizens’ welfare, particularly criticizing the stagnation in healthcare development in the Sunderban region. Chief Justice TS Sivagnanam, presiding over the division bench, expressed deep dissatisfaction with the state’s healthcare policies during the hearing of a petition related to the non-upgradation of a primary health center (PHC).
The petition was brought forth by a social worker from Sunderban, who claimed that his ancestors had donated approximately 13 bighas of land to the government in 1976 for the expansion of a local 10-bed PHC. Despite decades passing, there has been no progress, and the facility remains outdated and insufficient for the current needs.
Highlighting the contrast between the festive decorations in Kolkata and the grim reality of healthcare in rural areas, Chief Justice Sivagnanam remarked, “You are so proud of the lights in Park Street during Christmas. People are suffering and the health department takes a stand that the 10-bed hospital built in 1976 is more than sufficient.”
The court was informed of alternative plans by the state government to implement a mega surface water supply scheme on the donated land, which aims to provide water to people in 11 blocks, rather than enhancing healthcare facilities.
Drawing a comparison with healthcare facilities in his home state of Tamil Nadu, Chief Justice Sivagnanam highlighted the proactive nature of medical services there, including regular medical camps and school visits by doctors, setting a stark contrast to the situation in West Bengal.
The Sunderban area, known for its challenging geography with about 102 islands, half of which are inhabited, relies solely on boats for transport, further complicating access to medical care.
Chief Justice Sivagnanam also commented on the bureaucratic hurdles that impede progress, stating, “If there is a will there is a way. Bureaucrats can’t function if there is no political will. The principal secretary can do nothing. He has got daggers above his head. They need to protect their office and themselves also.”
The state’s counsel assured the court that the health center would be upgraded to a 25-bed medical facility following the court’s directives. However, the Chief Justice lamented the overall lack of initiative, saying, “It is very shameful for us. Even for providing a wheelchair we have to issue directions. You have to change the employment policy. How do the courts instill discipline in contractual workers?”
